Cellulose vs Fiberglass Insulation: Which Is Better for Your Attic?

ENERGY STAR reports that 9 out of 10 homes in the U.S. are under-insulated. If you are one of those homeowners, the first big choice is the material. For most attics, that means choosing between cellulose and fiberglass. Together they are the two most common materials blown onto attic floors.

Both work. Neither is best in every home. They differ in R-value per inch, weight, settling, fire behavior, moisture handling, and how they deal with air movement. This guide compares them point by point, with sample calculations and specific advice for Las Vegas attics, so you can pick the right one for your home.

Cellulose vs fiberglass: quick comparison

Factor Cellulose (loose-fill) Fiberglass (loose-fill and batts)
Made from Recycled paper, mostly newsprint, treated with fire retardants Spun glass fibers from sand and recycled glass
R-value per inch About R-3.2 to R-3.8 Loose-fill about R-2.2 to R-2.7; batts about R-3.1 to R-3.4
Forms Loose-fill, dense-pack, damp-spray Batts, rolls, loose-fill
Settling Settles in the first months; installed deeper to allow for it Very little settling
Air movement through it Resists air movement better Air passes through more easily
Weight About 2 to 3 times heavier per cubic foot Very light
Fire Treated to resist fire; paper itself can burn Glass fibers do not burn
Water Absorbs water; can clump if wet Does not absorb water; can hold it against drywall
Installation dust Dustier Less dust, but fibers can itch
Typical attic cost Similar; roughly $1 to $3 per sq ft installed Similar; roughly $1 to $3 per sq ft installed

What is cellulose insulation?

Cellulose is made by shredding recycled paper, mostly old newspaper, into small fibers. The fibers are mixed with fire-retardant chemicals, most often borates such as boric acid. The same treatment also makes the material less attractive to insects.

For attics, cellulose is almost always blown in as loose-fill. For closed walls, it can be dense-packed into cavities through small holes. In new construction, it can be sprayed damp into open walls. You will not find cellulose batts. More detail on how we install it is on our cellulose insulation page.

What is fiberglass insulation?

Fiberglass is made by melting sand and recycled glass and spinning it into very fine fibers. It comes in two main forms:

  • Batts and rolls: Pre-cut blankets sized to fit between standard framing. They are easy to handle and common in DIY work. See our fiberglass batt insulation page.
  • Loose-fill (blowing wool): Chopped fiberglass blown onto attic floors or into wall cavities with a machine. See our blown-in insulation page.

Because fiberglass comes in both forms, “cellulose vs fiberglass” can mean two different comparisons. In an attic, the fairest comparison is loose-fill cellulose against loose-fill fiberglass. That is the focus of most of this guide.

Which has the higher R-value, cellulose or fiberglass?

R-value per inch

Per inch, loose-fill cellulose has the higher R-value. It usually rates about R-3.2 to R-3.8 per inch. Loose-fill fiberglass rates about R-2.2 to R-2.7 per inch. Attic loose-fill cellulose is typically at the lower end of its range, around R-3.2 per inch. Dense-packed cellulose in walls reaches the higher numbers.

Fiberglass batts rate higher per inch than loose-fill fiberglass, but only when they fill the cavity with no gaps or compression.

Total R-value is what matters

Per-inch numbers only tell you how deep the insulation must be. Your comfort and energy bill depend on the total R-value across the whole attic. R-38 of fiberglass and R-38 of cellulose resist heat flow by the same amount. The fiberglass layer will simply be thicker. Our attic insulation R-value guide explains the targets in detail.

In Las Vegas, Climate Zone 3B, the Southern Nevada amendments to the 2024 IECC set a minimum of R-38 for ceilings in new work, effective January 11, 2026 in Clark County. ENERGY STAR recommends R-49 for an uninsulated Zone 3 attic, or adding R-38 if you already have 3 to 4 inches.

Sample calculation: depth for R-38 and R-49

Using typical mid-range values of R-2.5 per inch for loose-fill fiberglass and R-3.2 per inch for settled cellulose:

  • R-38 with fiberglass: 38 ÷ 2.5 = about 15 inches
  • R-38 with cellulose: 38 ÷ 3.2 = about 12 inches settled
  • R-49 with fiberglass: 49 ÷ 2.5 = about 19.5 inches
  • R-49 with cellulose: 49 ÷ 3.2 = about 15.3 inches settled

Depth matters in low-slope roofs. Near the edges of the attic, there may not be room for 19 or 20 inches of fiberglass over the exterior walls. Cellulose reaches the same R-value in less space, which can help at the edges. The exact depths for any product are printed on its bag. Always follow the manufacturer’s chart.

Does cellulose settle more than fiberglass?

Yes. Loose-fill cellulose settles as it compresses under its own weight and from everyday vibration. Industry references put attic settling at up to about 20% over the first several months. Blown-in fiberglass settles very little unless it was fluffed up too much during installation.

Settling is expected and does not mean the product failed. Under federal labeling rules, loose-fill makers must rate the R-value at the settled density. Their charts list both the initial thickness to install and the settled thickness you will end up with. A good installer blows cellulose to the initial thickness so that it still meets your target after settling. Problems start only when an installer blows cellulose to the settled number, which leaves you short on R-value.

Which blocks air movement better?

Cellulose resists air movement better than loose-fill fiberglass. Its fibers are denser and pack more tightly, so air has a harder time flowing through the layer. Loose fiberglass is more open and acts more like an air filter than an air blocker.

This gives cellulose a practical edge in attics with many small leaks that are hard to reach. Still, neither material is an air barrier. The Southern Nevada code amendments state that air-permeable insulation cannot be used as a sealing material. Whichever you choose, seal the gaps around lights, pipes, wires, and top plates with proper sealants first.

How do cellulose and fiberglass handle Las Vegas heat?

Both perform well in desert heat when installed at the right depth. A few local factors can tip the choice.

Summer heat flow favors both. In summer, the hot air sits above your insulation and does not sink into it. That keeps both materials stable and close to their rated R-values. Light loose-fill fiberglass can lose some R-value from air currents in very cold attics, but that is a winter problem in cold regions, not a Las Vegas summer one.

Wind at the eaves matters more for fiberglass. Air enters the attic through soffit vents at the roof edge. Loose fiberglass is light and can be pushed around by that airflow, leaving thin spots along the edges. Heavier cellulose stays put better. The fix for either material is the same: the code requires baffles at soffit vents and sealed bird blocks.

Dry air favors cellulose. Cellulose’s main weakness is water. The Las Vegas air is dry, so moisture from humidity is rarely an issue. The real risk is a roof leak during monsoon season.

Attic ducts are common here. Many Las Vegas homes have ducts and the air handler in the attic. Both materials can be blown around and over low ducts. Cellulose’s density can help cover irregular shapes, and fiberglass is easier to move aside later for duct repairs.

Which is safer in a fire?

Fiberglass itself does not burn, because glass fibers are not combustible. The paper facing on some batts can burn, which is why faced batts must not be left exposed in certain areas.

Cellulose is paper, which can burn, so it is treated with fire retardants. Cellulose sold for homes must meet a federal standard. The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s cellulose insulation standard (16 CFR Part 1209) sets requirements for flame resistance and corrosiveness. Every bag must carry a statement that the product meets it. Treated cellulose resists flame spread well. Like any material, it still needs proper clearance from heat sources such as non-IC recessed lights, flues, and chimneys.

For most homes, either material is safe when installed to code. If your attic has older light fixtures or heat-producing equipment you cannot move, fiberglass leaves a little more margin.

How do they handle moisture and roof leaks?

Fiberglass does not absorb water. If a small amount of water reaches it, the water tends to pass through or sit on the drywall below. The fibers can dry out, but wet fiberglass that has collapsed or picked up dirt will not return to its full R-value.

Cellulose absorbs water. A leak can make it clump, lose loft, and get much heavier, which adds stress to the ceiling below. The borate treatment helps it resist mold, but soaked cellulose should be removed and replaced rather than left to dry in place.

In practice, the lesson is the same for both materials. Fix roof leaks quickly and inspect the insulation after any leak.

Is the weight of cellulose a problem for your ceiling?

Cellulose is heavier. Older U.S. Gypsum guidance lists cellulose at about 2.5 to 3 pounds per cubic foot, against about 1 pound for fiberglass. The same guidance limits the insulation load on 1/2-inch drywall hung across framing spaced 24 inches apart to 1.3 pounds per square foot. That equals only about 6 inches of cellulose. With 5/8-inch drywall, the limit rises to 2.2 pounds per square foot, or about 10 inches of cellulose.

Here is what that means at R-38. About 12 inches of settled cellulose at roughly 2.3 pounds per cubic foot weighs about 2.3 pounds per square foot (12 ÷ 12 × 2.3). That is above the older guideline for 1/2-inch drywall on 24-inch spacing. Fiberglass makers report that loose-fill fiberglass can go up to R-70 over 1/2-inch drywall on 24-inch spacing without sag.

In the real world, sagging from thick attic cellulose is uncommon, and many building scientists consider the older guideline cautious. Still, it is worth checking. Ask your installer to confirm your drywall thickness and framing spacing, especially in older homes, homes with past roof leaks, or ceilings that already show sagging. Also ask whether the ceiling can carry the load before going above R-38 with cellulose.

Which is better for health and indoor air?

Both are considered safe once installed and sealed off from your living space. The differences mostly show up during installation.

Fiberglass fibers can irritate skin, eyes, and lungs while you handle them, which is why installers wear long sleeves, gloves, goggles, and a respirator. In 2001, the International Agency for Research on Cancer moved glass wool insulation to Group 3, meaning it is not classifiable as a cancer-causing agent in humans.

Cellulose is less itchy but much dustier to install. Installers should wear respirators, and the attic hatch should stay sealed during the work. Once in place and covered by an air-sealed ceiling, neither material should affect your indoor air.

Which is better for pests and mold?

The borate treatment in cellulose makes it less appealing to insects and helps it resist mold growth. Fiberglass does not feed mold because glass is not food for it, but dust and debris trapped in fiberglass can support mold if it stays wet.

Neither material keeps rodents out. Mice and rats can nest in either one. If you have had rodents, seal their entry points and remove contaminated insulation before adding anything new.

Which is more eco-friendly?

Cellulose has the edge on recycled content. The Department of Energy notes that cellulose is made primarily from recycled newsprint and that most fiberglass products contain 40% to 60% recycled glass. Cellulose also takes less energy to make, because fiberglass requires melting glass in high-heat furnaces.

Fiberglass does have one lasting benefit: it does not break down over time and keeps working for decades if it stays dry and undisturbed. For most homeowners, the energy saved by having enough insulation of either type is far larger than the difference in how they are made.

Which costs more?

In most markets, the two cost about the same for attic work. National 2026 cost guides place both blown-in cellulose and blown-in fiberglass at roughly $1 to $3 per square foot installed for a standard attic top-up. Cellulose is sometimes slightly cheaper per R-value because you need fewer inches. Fiberglass bags are lighter, and some crews prefer them. Local supply and crew experience usually decide which one is cheaper near you.

The bigger cost drivers are air sealing, removing old or damaged insulation, attic access, and the R-value you choose. For local price ranges, see our guide to attic insulation cost in Nevada.

Can you install cellulose or fiberglass yourself?

Fiberglass batts are the easiest DIY option in an open attic with standard framing. They need careful cutting to avoid gaps. Both loose-fill products can be blown by a homeowner with a rented machine. The challenge is doing it well: air sealing first, installing baffles, reaching the right depth everywhere, and staying safe.

In Las Vegas, attic heat is a serious safety issue. Summer attic temperatures can rise far above the outdoor temperature, and heat illness can set in quickly. If you do the work yourself, plan it for the cooler months and early mornings.

Which should you choose for a Las Vegas attic?

Both are good choices here. Use your attic’s conditions to decide.

Choose cellulose if:

  • Your attic has many small air leaks or complex framing you cannot fully seal
  • The edges of your attic have little height and you need more R-value in less space
  • Your roof is in good condition with no history of leaks
  • Your ceiling drywall and framing can carry the added weight at your target R-value

Choose fiberglass if:

  • Your ceilings use 1/2-inch drywall on wide framing, or show any sagging
  • Your roof has had leaks or you expect roof work soon
  • Your attic has older fixtures or equipment that need extra fire margin
  • You expect to move insulation often for duct or electrical work

Either one works if your attic is air sealed, baffled, and filled to at least R-38. In Las Vegas, the details of the installation affect your comfort more than the material does. To compare these two with spray foam, mineral wool, and radiant barriers, see our guide to attic insulation types.

Frequently asked questions

Can you blow cellulose on top of existing fiberglass?

Yes. Adding cellulose over old fiberglass batts or loose-fill is common and works well. The denser cellulose layer can even reduce air movement through the fiberglass below. Just make sure the old insulation is dry and clean, and that the combined weight is safe for your ceiling.

Do I have to remove old insulation before adding new?

Usually not. If your existing insulation is dry, free of rodent contamination, and not moldy, you can add new material on top. Remove it if it is wet, damaged, or contaminated, or if air sealing work needs clear access to the attic floor. Our guide on when to replace attic insulation covers the warning signs.

Does the color of fiberglass insulation matter?

No. Pink, yellow, white, and brown fiberglass differ mainly by brand and binder, not by performance. What matters is the R-value printed on the bag or batt label. Always compare products by their stated R-value and coverage chart.

How long do cellulose and fiberglass last?

Both can last for decades if they stay dry, clean, and uncompressed. The most common reasons to replace them are roof leaks, rodent damage, and compression from foot traffic or storage. Settling in cellulose is a one-time event that correct installation already accounts for.

Which is better for reducing noise between rooms?

For interior walls and floors, dense-packed cellulose generally blocks more sound than fiberglass batts, because it is denser and fills the cavity completely. Fiberglass batts made for sound control also help. Neither will fully soundproof a room without other changes, such as sealing gaps and adding drywall mass.

Does the building code require one material over the other?

No. The Clark County energy code sets minimum R-values, not specific materials. Both cellulose and fiberglass meet the code when installed to the required R-value with baffles, depth markers, and air sealing.

Conclusion

Cellulose gives you more R-value per inch and better resistance to air movement. Fiberglass is lighter, resists water, and does not burn. In a dry climate like Las Vegas, both perform well. The deciding factors are usually your ceiling’s strength, your roof’s condition, and how leaky your attic is. Whichever you choose, aim for at least R-38, seal air leaks first, and keep the eave vents clear with baffles. If you want help choosing, our attic insulation company can inspect your attic and recommend the right material and depth for your home.

Get a Quote